Essay about Minority and majority rights - 1792 Words

The rights of many people versus the rights of an individual is certainly a vexing concept. Like a delicate balancing act; if one side is favoured over the other it causes a rift in the already strained relationship between the minority and majority. Evidently, the justification of taking any side must be valid, according to the theories of H.L.A. Hart. In the past, Canadian law has violated the rights of minorities; however, these violations have decreased in their severity as time has passed on. Some cases where the balance between minority and majority rights is questioned is in The Canadian Indian Residential School System, Bill 101, Equality in the Workplace and The Public Service Act. To begin, Aboriginal rights have, historically,†¦show more content†¦The Act was amended for the first time in 1885, the amendment prohibited religious practices and traditional dances. The validity of these laws is questionable. According to H.L.A. Hart’s philosophies: these measures were not valid. Laws are to protect society from exploitation and violence of the weak and vulnerable; instead children were taken out of their homes and forced into a new strange environment where they were likely abused. One of Hart’s theories says that: for a law to be valid, rules should be obeyed because they make sense, not because of the fear of punishment. In these residential schools the Children were forced to dress, speak and act in a European manner – they would receive harsh punishments otherwise; clearly, this is not valid. It was a serious violation of human rights for a minority group in the human population. Canada has recognized this and in 2007 a 1.9 bill ion dollar compensation package was put together for those who attended residential schools; a formal apology was also delivered by Stephen Harper to residential school students in 2008. Therefore, Canada has severely violated the rights of the Aboriginal minority in the interest to assimilate them into Canadian society; the mistake was recognized and compensation was given. It is no secret that French-English relations in Canada have been strained in the past and still are – albeit to a lesser extent.Show MoreRelatedMinority And Majority Rights : Canada1389 Words   |  6 Pages Minority and Majority Rights in Canada Olivia Gomes CLU 4U1 Mr. McCormick Tuesday, November 11, 2014 In recent decades of Canadian history, Canada’s social and political change has rapidly formed visible minority and majority groups- Canada has had formally entrenched a constitution, withstood two attempts by the Quebec’s provincial government to secede from the federation, and undertaken a radical shift in immigration policy that tripled the visible minority population. These changesRead MoreThe Concept Of Majority Rule With Minority Rights Essay1336 Words   |  6 Pagesof majority rule with minority rights. This is an idea formed from the principles of democracy that encompass American government. We must analyze democracy and compare it to the American government. Minority rights should be understood as those that are unalienable; human rights exempt from persecution. From this information, we will understand when, if ever, it is ok to impose one’s will over another Democracy is a government in which citizens make political decisions based on majority ruleRead MoreComparing Foss V Harbottle Rule And Derivative Action1664 Words   |  7 PagesIntroduction The protections under the Corporations Act suffice to guard the minority from the majority’s unfair wrongdoing. In fact, the Australian corporate law provides significant protections on shareholders. To support the argument, this essay discusses Foss v Harbottle rule and derivative action. It also elaborates exceptions to the rule, especially ‘fraud on the minority’ and statutory protections available for the minority protection under the Corporations Act. These are analysed in views of organicRead MoreMinority Shareholder Rights- Case780 Words   |  4 PagesTo: Joe Brock From: Sue Smith, CPA Subject: Minority Shareholder Rights Facts: Joe Brock is a minority interest shareholder in Big Corporation. Leslie Ross is a shareholder that owns less than 50% of the voting shares, but has the majority of the voting shares and thus has taken control of the corporation. According to SFAS 94, due to this control, Leslie Ross must consolidate his interest with Big Corporation. Mark Jones, a minority shareholder, is in a position of management for the companyRead MoreMinority And Minority Groups726 Words   |  3 Pagesform of minorities. There are immigrants, indigenous peoples, handicapped people, and in many societies women, etc. In every society there is also a sense of pride for the people who may consider themselves true Canadians for example. This is called nation-building. In other words, it allows people to build their identities. The majority and the minority get to experience nation-building. Since the majority has a stronger chance at building an identity the state grants rights to the minority groupsRead MoreThe I mportance Of Minority Rights826 Words   |  4 Pagesthe rights of the minority groups. Some minority rights seem to conflict with liberal rights, for an example forcing women to stay home. (Freedman, 30 October 2017). In this essay, I will argue that the state should not endorse rights that infringes with the equality of the rights of a minority, therefore inhibiting the state’s ability to treat all of its citizens with equal concern and respect. Bill 62 and African Americans are two examples of the majority not being tolerant of the minorities rightsRead MoreProtecting interest of the minority Shareholders1625 Words   |  7 Pagesï » ¿Protecting interest of the minority Shareholders M S Siddiqui Legal Economist and pursuing PhD in Open University, Malaysia e-mail: shah@banglachemical.com The over-investment by directors is not good for the stock market and it should be addressed properly to find a way out and safeguard interest of minority shareholders from the experience of other markets, writes M S Siddiqui†¦Ã¢â‚¬ ¦Ã¢â‚¬ ¦Ã¢â‚¬ ¦Ã¢â‚¬ ¦Ã¢â‚¬ ¦. http://www.thefinancialexpress-bd.com/2013/11/25/5614 In Asian countries including Bangladesh, theRead MoreJames Madison s Ideology Of Democracy1504 Words   |  7 PagesAmerican citizens have many rights and freedoms protected by the constitution and laws passed by the United States government. The United States is the land of the free, the home of the brave, where all men are created equal, and where one has the right to land, liberty, and property. However, for some Americans, it has not always been an easy journey to having these basic rights that all Americans are theoretically born with. African Americans are one of the groups that have been oppressed for centuriesRead More Affirmative Action: Keeping minorities down for 30 years. Essay1509 Words   |  7 Pages nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;The subject of affirmative action in college admissions has been hotly debated since its inception. Although affirmative action was originally supported by the vast majority, that same majority is now starting to wonder if there is a better way. Commonly asked questions include: â€Å"Is affirmative action still working?† and â€Å"Is there an alternative?† The answers to each of these questions will provide insurmountable evidence that affirmative action in college admissionsRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book Romeo And Juliet And Great Expectations 1662 Words   |  7 Pageslibraries, The House on Mango Street and Uncle Tom’s Cabin are hidden away, stories of minorities boxed in by cardboard and majority rule. While America’s student body becomes increasingly diverse (and schools rush to adapt), some say curriculum has stayed monochromatic by regularly painting the story of the white majority while failing to represent minority backgrounds and experiences fairly and leaving minority students struggling to relate to texts presented in the classroom. Others say the American